Skip to main content
promotional banner for can you prove your CC^ checklist
Should Regulators Get a Legal Basis to Swap Case Data?Consent Principles
4 min readFor Compliance Managers

Should Regulators Get a Legal Basis to Swap Case Data?

The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) has written to the European Commission about establishing a legal basis for cross-regulatory exchange of information. While the letter's subject is specific, the underlying question is crucial for compliance managers operating across borders. Should data protection authorities (DPAs) be able to share information with other regulators under a dedicated legal framework, or should they continue using existing cooperation tools?

The Question at Hand

Currently, coordinated supervision by DPAs is managed through the Cooperation and Supervision Committee (CSC). This mechanism operates within current legal boundaries. The EDPB's letter highlights a gap: when regulators from different fields or jurisdictions want to exchange information about the same organization, they need a clear legal basis.

For you, the stakes are clear. A single processing activity, like deploying a Consent Management Platform that activates Non-Essential Cookies before Prior Consent, can involve data protection law, ePrivacy rules, and consumer or competition law. Whether regulators can compare notes, and on what authority, affects how many separate inquiries you might face and the consistency of outcomes.

The Case for a Dedicated Legal Basis

Supporters of the EDPB's position offer three main arguments.

Legal Certainty for Regulators. Authorities sharing information without a clear statutory basis risk challenges from the organizations they supervise. A defined legal basis removes that risk, allowing regulators to cooperate without questioning their own authority.

Consistency for Regulated Entities. Fragmented enforcement increases compliance costs. If one authority interprets your Consent Notice as providing Genuine Choice and another disagrees, you're left reconciling two positions without a shared reference point. Structured exchange reduces the chances of contradictory findings on identical facts.

Enhanced Coordination for the CSC. The CSC exists to ensure coordinated supervision. Proponents argue a legal basis would strengthen this mandate, providing firmer ground for necessary information flows.

For compliance teams, this approach offers a net benefit: more predictable enforcement and fewer surprises from informal regulatory channels.

The Case for Current Mechanisms

Skeptics aren't against cooperation. Their concerns focus on scope, proportionality, and the position of supervised organizations.

Information Sharing Cuts Both Ways. A formal channel that enhances regulatory efficiency also increases the likelihood that your disclosures to one authority will reach another. Information provided in a data protection inquiry could inform a parallel proceeding under a different regime, with different procedural protections.

Purpose Limitation Applies to Regulators Too. Data collected for one supervisory purpose shouldn't flow freely into another. Critics argue that any new legal basis must be tightly bounded to avoid undermining principles DPAs enforce on others.

Existing Tools May Suffice. The CSC already coordinates supervision. Some argue it's better to use current cooperation procedures more effectively than to build new legal structures, which could have unintended consequences.

Operationally, greater regulatory coordination increases the cost of weak compliance. If your Consent Fatigue mitigation is inadequate and your records of Valid Consent are inconsistent, a more connected enforcement environment will expose these weaknesses faster.

Where Practitioners Actually Land

Most compliance teams focus on two outcomes: predictability and proportionality.

On predictability, practitioners generally welcome clearer rules. Few teams want to discover that an informal exchange between authorities shaped an unexpected inquiry. A defined basis, with defined limits, is easier to plan around than ambiguous practices.

On proportionality, the concern is about guardrails. Practitioners want clarity on what information can move, between which authorities, for what purposes, and with what notice to the organization. Without these answers, "legal basis" is just a phrase.

There's also a consensus on global data transfer arrangements. Any framework changing how EU authorities exchange information will eventually affect interactions with non-EU counterparts. Teams managing transfers under adequacy decisions or contractual safeguards should watch this development closely. While the letter addresses the need for a legal basis, the impact on transfer agreements remains an area with more questions than answers for now.

Our Take

A legal basis for cross-regulatory information exchange is a step in the right direction, provided the limits are as carefully defined as the permissions.

Regulators sharing information under clear statutory authority are more accountable than those sharing it informally. Authority can be reviewed, challenged, and narrowed. Informal practice can't. This transparency favors the EDPB's call and benefits you, as it provides a framework to hold regulators accountable.

However, the skeptics' concerns about risks are valid. If the framework is too broad, the real cost falls on organizations that cooperate honestly with one regulator, only to find their statements shared more widely than expected. The Commission should insist on purpose limits, notice to affected organizations where feasible, and clear rules on what can be shared.

In the meantime, prepare by treating every regulatory submission as if a second authority will read it. Keep your records of Valid Consent, cookie audit results, and Purpose Disclosure language consistent across jurisdictions. If your documentation tells one story to one regulator and a different story elsewhere, a more connected enforcement environment will expose the gap. If it tells the same defensible story everywhere, closer regulatory cooperation is manageable.

The EDPB has opened the question. The Commission's response will determine the level of cooperation and protection you can expect.

Promotional banner for the Pentest Readiness checklist download

You Might Also Like